Judge rules UNC non-admittance of white and Asian students, race-based admissions not discriminatory

Judge rules UNC non-admittance of white and Asian students, race-based admissions not discriminatory

October 20, 2021
A federal judge endorsed the University of North Carolina’s (UNC) use of race as a factor in screening applicants after ruling that the university did not discriminate against white and Asian American applicants.
No discrimination: Judge Loretta Biggs ruled on Monday that the UNC’s undergraduate admissions process had not been discriminatory toward specific race groups, reported CNN.
  • The group Students for Fair Admissions alleged in its 2014 lawsuit that UNC deliberately discriminated against certain members by including race in its admissions process.
  • According to the suit, UNC allegedly used “racial preferences in undergraduate admissions where there are available race-neutral alternatives capable of achieving student body diversity,” and employed “an undergraduate admissions policy that uses race as a factor in admissions.”
  • Biggs argued, however, that UNC engages in “a highly individualized, holistic admissions program.”
  • According to Briggs, the university clearly demonstrated that its undergraduate admissions program “withstands strict scrutiny and is therefore constitutionally permissible.”
  • The judge further wrote: “While no student can or should be admitted to this University, or any other, based solely on race, because race is so interwoven in every aspect of the lived experience of minority students, to ignore it, reduce its importance and measure it only by statistical models as SFFA has done, misses important context to include obscuring racial barriers and obstacles that have been faced, overcome and are yet to be overcome.”
Subscribe to
NextShark's Newsletter

A daily dose of Asian America's essential stories, in under 5 minutes.

Get our collection of Asian America's most essential stories to your inbox daily for free.

Unsure? Check out our Newsletter Archive.

Upholding discriminatory policies: While the UNC welcomed the ruling, the SFFA expressed disappointment in how the court allegedly “upheld UNC’s discriminatory admissions policies.”
  • In a press statement, SFFA President Edward Blum said that they intend to file an appeal to the Fourth Court of Appeals and to the U.S. Supreme Court.
  • “We believe that the documents, emails, data analysis and depositions SFFA presented at trial compellingly revealed UNC’s systematic discrimination against non-minority applicants,” Blum added.
  • Office of University Communications Associate Vice Chancellor Beth Keith said in a statement that the ruling proved that UNC’s “holistic admissions approach is lawful.”
  • “We evaluate each student in a deliberate and thoughtful way, appreciating individual strengths, talents and contributions to a vibrant campus community where students from all backgrounds can excel and thrive,” she said.
  • Based on data from the UNC website, the incoming 5,630 students this year are composed of 65% who identified as White or Caucasian, 21% as Asian or Asian American, 12% as Black or African American and 10% who said they were Hispanic, Latina or Latino.
A similar lawsuit filed by SFFA against Harvard University in 2014 received the same ruling in 2019, NextShark previously reported. The Supreme Court effectively postponed action on it in June.
Featured Image via Colin Rowley
      Ryan General

      Ryan General is a Senior Reporter for NextShark




      Many people might not know this, but NextShark is a small media startup that runs on no outside funding or loans, and with no paywalls or subscription fees, we rely on help from our community and readers like you.

      Everything you see today is built by Asians, for Asians to help amplify our voices globally and support each other. However, we still face many difficulties in our industry because of our commitment to accessible and informational Asian news coverage.

      We hope you consider making a contribution to NextShark so we can continue to provide you quality journalism that informs, educates, and inspires the Asian community. Even a $1 contribution goes a long way. Thank you for supporting NextShark and our community.

      © 2023 NextShark, Inc. All rights reserved.