Boston Globe under fire for using slain Asians’ image in op-ed on whether Asians benefit from ‘whiteness’

  • The Boston Globe has come under fire for using an image that features Asian victims of violence in an op-ed that questions whether Asians are victims of racism or beneficiaries of white privilege.
  • The newspaper originally published a cover image of anti-affirmative action protesters, but the author of the article, Natasha Warikoo, asked to have it changed.
  • It’s unclear who exactly chose the replacement, which now shows illustrated portraits of the late Michelle Go, Vicha Ratanapakdee and other Asian victims of violence.
  • Designer Jonathan D. Chang, who illustrated the portraits, was among those who criticized the cover choice, writing “What the f*ck?”
  • Others took offense directly to Warikoo’s writing, with one accusing her of being racist herself.

The Boston Globe has come under fire for using an image that features Asian victims of violence — with the late Michelle Go at the center — in an opinion piece that questions whether Asians are victims of racism or beneficiaries of white privilege.

The newspaper originally published a cover image of anti-affirmative action protesters to go with the story. However, the author of the article, Natasha Warikoo, asked to have it replaced because it was “precisely the kind of simplistic thinking I was arguing against.”

“Yes, there’s anti-Asian discrimination, but no, college admissions is generally not the place you’ll see it,” Warikoo, who is currently a professor of sociology at Tufts University, wrote in a Twitter thread.

“To their credit, the paper quickly changed the image when I wrote [to] the editor, but the image still appears, annoyingly, when you tweet the article. Thankfully not in print edition!”

It’s unclear who exactly chose the replacement image, which is now a photo taken during a candlelight vigil held in honor of Michelle Go. The 40-year-old, who advocated for the homeless, died after being pushed by a homeless man into the path of an approaching subway train in New York City in January.

The new cover image shows a Times Square billboard that featured illustrated portraits of Go and other Asian victims of violence. Among them was Vicha Ratanapakdee, who also died after being shoved to the ground in San Francisco last year.

The replacement did not sit well with several members of the Asian American community — including designer Jonathan D. Chang, who illustrated the portraits.

“Could have chosen any other image for this op-ed but chose my Times Square portraits of Asians who were murdered to talk about Asians being ‘beneficiaries of whiteness,’” Chang wrote in an Instagram Story. “What the f*ck?”

Image via @jdschang

“You in particular need to keep working class yellow folk out of your upper class academic, white-adjacent mouth,” Twitter user @dotorii_muk wrote. “It’s really an academic bubble moment when you’re using a cover photo of Asians protesting literal murders — lives lost to violent racism, mostly in low-income and first-generation communities, to talk about (checks notes) Harvard admissions.”

“When you answer the question with your own cover photo but you can’t resist having others hear what you think even though the topic significantly deviates from the cover photo,” Twitter user @DragonCombatCl1 wrote.

Instagram user @mcasianlife called Warikoo’s op-ed “trash” and created a meme in frustration:

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by McAsianLife (@mcasianlife)

Meanwhile, others took offense directly to what they perceived as the “erasure of working class Asians” in Warikoo’s writing:

One user even accused Warikoo of being racist herself:

The cover image remains live as of this writing.

Featured Image (Representation Only) via CBS New York

Total
20
Shares
Related Posts